If you’ve had a baby in New York City, you know the question. Before “boy or girl?”, it’s “do you have a night nurse? just nights, or 24/7? for how many weeks?”
I know exactly how that sounds. To most of the world, hiring someone to come to your home overnight so you can sleep through your newborn’s wakeups is an unimaginable luxury, a problem most people would love to have. But in a lot of NYC parenting circles, it isn’t treated like a luxury at all. It’s just the default, the first thing people ask, right up there with “when are you due?” So before I tell you this story, I want to be clear: I know how privileged the whole conversation is. This is a “problem” most people will never have.
Here’s what happened anyway.
The cancellation
I had a night nurse booked. Of course I did. It’s what you do here. I’d checked the box months earlier and gone back to the business of being very pregnant and waiting.
Then, about a week before my due date, she had an emergency and could no longer take the job. And to her credit, the moment she knew, she sent me a referral, someone ready to step in. The off-ramp was right there, easy.
I didn’t take it.
And it wasn’t just her one referral. When I told friends and family the night nurse had fallen through, my phone lit up. Everyone wanted to help. Within a day I had something like twenty referrals.
But I wasn’t panicking.
I could have replaced her in an afternoon. The whole village was standing by to make it happen. But as soon as it fell through, something in my gut told me not to replace her, and that I could do the nights myself.
Let me be honest about the fear
I don’t want to make this sound braver than it was. I was scared of the overnight wakeups. That part was real. The wakeups are the thing every new parent dreads, and for good reason: the not-knowing of it. Why is he up? Is he hungry? Is something wrong? Will I ever sleep again?
So no, I wasn’t fearless. I was just not panicked. There’s a difference, and it took me a minute to understand it myself.
Why “no fallback” turned out to be the gift
Here’s the thing I didn’t expect, and it’s the whole reason I’m writing this:
Having no one coming to rescue me is exactly what built my confidence.
When there’s no one scheduled to take the 2am shift, you stop waiting to be rescued and you start figuring it out. And that, not a book, not someone on a rollaway bed in the nursery, is how the confidence actually gets built. By being the one who shows up, night after night, and slowly realizing: oh. I can do this.
And, let’s be honest, there’s a not-small bonus here that has nothing to do with personal growth: I saved a staggering amount of money. Night nurses are not cheap, and “I learned I could do it myself” came with a generous side of “and I kept thousands of dollars in the process.”
I’d spent my whole pregnancy getting certified in pediatric sleep. So at 3am, I wasn’t guessing. I knew a baby stirring between sleep cycles is normal and doesn’t always need me to come running. I knew the difference between a real wakeup and just noise. I knew what newborn sleep is actually supposed to look like, so I wasn’t thrown by things that were completely, biologically fine.
That knowledge didn’t make the nights easy. It made them manageable. And the gap between those two words is everything.
What I actually want you to take from this
If you have help, a night nurse, a postpartum doula, a partner who splits the shifts, your mom for two weeks, that’s a gift, take it. I almost did.
But if you don’t, if it’s not in the budget, or it fell through: you may be far more capable of the newborn nights than this city tells you.
So much of what makes those nights terrifying isn’t the actual work. It’s the not-knowing. And the not-knowing is fixable. You don’t need someone in your home. You need to understand what’s happening with your baby, so that when you’re standing in the dark at 3am, you’re not afraid. You’re just tired. And tired, you can do.
That gap, between terrified and just tired, is the whole thing I help families close.
If you’d rather feel ready than scared
Whether there’s a newborn on the way or you’re already in the thick of it, I help families understand their baby’s sleep so the nights feel manageable instead of frightening. The first step is easy and free: fill out my quick intake form and tell me about your little one.
And if you just want more like this, subscribe.
I’m taking readers through whatever the four-month regression has in store for Jack, in real time, with a lot more honest sleep talk where this came from.
I’m a certified pediatric sleep consultant, and I provide sleep coaching and education, not medical advice. I’ll always tell you when something belongs with your pediatrician. Your child’s doctor is always your first call for any medical concern.



